Thursday, March 12, 2020

The world is ending, but at least I have my cards


Okay, so the post title might be a bit extreme, but there's a hint of truth in it.

There are many reasons we collect cards: some of the obvious ones being pure fun, love of the game, etc. But I think there's another big factor here that doesn't get discussed as often. Comfort. I collect cards because they are a reliable source of joy, a backbone for it all. I've been doing this long enough that I literally can't imagine my life without my collection, and over time it's brought me so much comfort in what can often be a mad, mad, mad, mad world.

Enjoying my cards -- simply sorting them, or looking through them -- has helped pass countless bad moons, and will surely pass many more in the future.




Even better: a collection is never complete, always growing, which provides all the more opportunities for joy and comfort.

I've received a few packages from loyal readers as of late that did their fair share in bulking up my binders. One came from a reader named Arthur who reached out and said he had a bunch of stuff from my various Opening Day want lists...and boy he wasn't kidding.

He took down about 90 percent of all the inserts listed on my OD need lists from 2015-present -- including some I've long loved ("Superstar Celebrations"), some I rarely see ("Team Spirit"), and others I'd completely forgotten about ("Hit the Dirt").




That also came with a similarly decimating attack on my recent OD base want lists as well, which I was happy to see.

I still have a soft spot for Opening Day, and I'm way more excited than I probably should be about (hopefully) finding some of the 2020s on Target shelves soon.




Jeff B., a reader who's sent me cards a few times now, knocked this '79 Topps Ted Simmons off my Dime Box Dozen list recently.

I'll probably have more in this in a future post, but I righted a longtime wrong and started collecting Simmons after his election to Cooperstown. Thankfully, I was able to secure most of Simba's base cards off Card Barrel, though a few obvious ones -- like this '79 Topps -- weren't available there and thus became gaping holes in said collection.

I've noticed a kind of awkward beauty to a lot of Simmons's cards, and this one definitely has that going for it.




Jeff also sent a couple parallel mini-collection hits along for the ride -- '90s Dufex rules!




I came home one night to find an entire box of cards from longtime reader Mike W. waiting for me -- I can't help but think I'm really not worthy of this whenever a big box o' cards arrives in the mail.

And after I opened it, I soon declared myself totally unworthy of the '91 BBM Hideo Nomo(!) Mike had so graciously included.




And if I'm unworthy of that, then how can I even begin to describe how I felt when I found second(!!) and third(!!!) BBM Nomos in there?!




Though they might take a bit of a backseat to the Nomos, don't sleep on the other oddballs Mike sent me (including my first Blues Brothers card!).




The perfect collision of books and baseball cards, my two favorite hobbies.




Announcer cards! Damn Yankees cards!




Nifty player- and mini-collection hits here, although I probably still have something like 8,454 of those Olerud Topps Tek patterns to chase down.




Finally comes some cards from Wes W., a generous reader I've known long and well from the insane kinds of packages he used to drop on me -- and while Wes settled for a much more modest PWE this time around, it still packed a heckuva punch.

Leading off was this '56 Topps Jack Meyer -- no, I have no idea who Jack Meyer is, but when someone sends you a free '56 you need not ask such questions.




Most of the PWE consisted of these excellent Target Dodgers even though I'm probably about the 186th most prolific Dodger collecter in the blogosphere.

I like big, sweeping team-issued sets like this because a lot of the cards in them (including almost all of the ones Wes sent) feature guys who were much more famous playing for other teams and/or were only Dodgers for a short time.




But one Target Dodger easily stood out among them all -- and that's the immortal Hoyt, of course!

There aren't many Dodger cards of Hoyt (this is only the sixth one I own), which kinda makes sense because he was a Dodger for all of 25 games at the tail end of his Hall of Fame career. And despite my many Hoyt-collecting years, this particular one lurked in the shadows until it arrived on my doorstep, which really is a fantastic way to discover a baseball card you never knew you needed.

So, sure, if the world is ending, so be it -- with all these cards waiting be sorted and loved, I'm willing to hole myself up in my room until need be.

Tuesday, March 10, 2020

The (Second) Dime Box Frankenset Bracket: Palmer Region (Pt. 2)


Let's see how last week's matchups played out.

#1 (Page 60) -- 1975 Topps #533 Rudy Meoli (20 votes)

def.

#16 (Page 27) -- 1974 Topps #238 Fran Healy (16 votes)




#8 (Page 50) -- 1994 Stadium Club #448 Erik Pappas (22 votes)

def.

#9 (Page 44) -- 2001 UD Victory #396 Wilton Guerrero (15 votes)




#5 (Page 1) -- 2018 Stadium Club #9 Zack Godley (23 votes)

def.

#12 (Page 67) -- 1969 Topps #603 Joe Keough (13 votes)




#4 (Page 54) -- 1996 Collector's Choice #484 Rex Hudler (25 votes)

def.

#13 (Page 21) -- 1977 Topps #187 Dick Pole (11 votes)

Not much drama here: we didn't see a single upset last week, and all the winners won fairly comfortably (with the 1-vs.-16 matchup actually being the closest of the bunch).

Between a dude eating, a dude diving into a swimming pool, and a dude milking a cow, I'd say this is already shaping up to be the most diverse region of the bracket.

--------------------------


And so we've come to the final four matchups of the bracket's first round -- after this we'll have the field narrowed down to 32.

Let's see the what's waiting with the rest of the Palmer Region.





#6 (Page 28) -- 1983 Fleer #249 Aurelio Rodriguez

VS.

#11 (Page 47) -- 1993 Upper Deck #415 Denny Neagle





#3 (Page 35) -- 1995 Upper Deck #312 Steve Buechele

VS.

#14 (Page 53) -- 1991 Score #475 Andy Van Slyke





#7 (Page 33) -- 1963 Topps #294 Bill Rigney

VS.

#10 (Page 15) -- 2001 Ultra #132 Matt Stairs





#2 (Page 74) -- 1992 Upper Deck #666 Bob Ojeda

VS.

#15 (Page 26) -- 1973 Topps #231 Bill Parsons

That's it for this week -- the polls are now on the sidebar.

Happy voting!

Thursday, March 5, 2020

Grading Heritage


Heritage is moving into extremely dangerous territory this year.

For the first time since 2014 when it honored '65 Topps, Heritage is featuring a design I love. My thoughts on the sets in between pretty much ranged from dislike ('68 Topps) to indifferent ('66 Topps) to mildly preferred ('67 Topps). And not only is this year's tribute to '71 a watershed event, but it begins a string of top-tier designs for me -- '71, '72, '73 and '75 are all in my Top 10 Topps Sets ever (and '74 isn't far off). I don't know about you, but I'm ready for the long string of Heritage excitement that awaits.

But while, yes, my attitude toward the original set is a vital (and, from Topps's standpoint, uncontrollable) factor in how I feel about Heritage in any given year, I think how I grade Heritage goes a bit further than that.




The question more becomes: Could I see this card in the actual, original set?

I'm not as much of a stickler for the specifics of the design as most others seem to be. Sure, I wish Topps would be a bit more attentive to the minutiae of faithfully reproducing a baseball card, but if there's an extra space between a name here or a shrunken font there it's not going to completely ruin Heritage for me. With me, it's more a matter of does the card evoke those feelings of the set it's supposed to honor? Does it make me want to go back through my binders and appreciate the originals all over again?

It's hard to say in words what this means, or how it's accomplished, but I can say that 2020 Heritage succeeds on this front -- I can, for instance, see all four of these cards as vintage '71s, and I especially appreciate the mixture of action and posed shots as per the originals (which I was worried Topps would ignore).




The backs are solid, though one failure for me is that Topps didn't use the strange, stunted English often found on vintage text ("Another fine year was 1970 for Jim...").




Heritage SPs continue to be a paradox for me: aggravating in theory but somewhat exciting to pull.

One could argue that even these stay faithful to the originals, as a handful of '71s were actually short-printed -- I still don't know why some vintage cards were SPs, though, as they're not the obvious cash grab present-day SPs are (printing issues, maybe?).




The subsets are cool, as usual -- though I can't help but imagine an asterisk over all the Astros ones.

I will once again be building the News Flashbacks insert set, and my lone New Age Performers pull inspired me to start a new player collection with Tim Anderson (hometown star, batting champ, what more do I need?).




Retail inserts continue to be underappreciated but wonderful.




I'm not the first to say this, nor will I be the last, but one recent trend I like with Heritage is that it's started to honor very specific cards.

Heritage is, in essence, one big tribute, but in the past it's seemed like merely a nod to the originals rather than a full-on embrace of it. There wasn't a Coke-bottle shades Ryne Duren tribute in any of the late '50s/early '60s Heritage, nor was there a batboy card in the '69 edition of Heritage tribute. Last year's immaculate Neshek/Palmer & Frazier/Harrelson mashups in honor of  a couple of '70 Topps's most memorable moments began a that spilled over into 2020 Heritage, thankfully.

First off is this Gary Sanchez, a terrific tribute to perhaps my favorite (and most expensive) '71 Topps card, the iconic Thurman Munson play at the plate.




But in terms of the card itself and its evocation of the original, I think I like Michael Conforto more.

For lack of a better term, it's got the weirdness that's missing from a lot of baseball cards these days. I'm not particularly sure what's going on there, nor do I know where exactly that photograph was taken from, but dang if it isn't amazing. I believe we need more mystery in our baseball cards. Plus it shares a card number (#50) with the similarly quirky '71 Topps card of fellow Met Tommie Agee, as well as the sacred runner-fielder-umpire triumvirate (also rare in today's hobby).

This is Heritage at its finest.




Like so precious few of my teachers growing up, I'm somewhat of an easy grader when it comes to Heritage, and I give this year's edition a solid B-plus/A-minus (probably closer to A-minus with the extra credit earned by the Sanchez & Conforto).

More than that, though, 2020 Heritage foreshadows all the excitement of the glorious '70s designs still to come.

Tuesday, March 3, 2020

The (Second) Dime Box Frankenset Bracket: Palmer Region (Pt. 1)


Had some close ones last week.

#6 (Page 12) -- 2017 Stadium Club #104 Ryon Healy (20 votes)

def.

#11 (Page 43) -- 1973 Topps #386 Don Money (15 votes)




#14 (Page 42) -- 1992 Stadium Club #376 Greg Gagne (17 votes)

def.

#3 (Page 19) -- 2004 Upper Deck #166 Kerry Robinson (16 votes)




#7 (Page 31) -- 1973 Topps #273 Chris Speier (24 votes)

def.

#10 (Page 2) -- 2007 Upper Deck #16 Alvin Colina (9 votes)




#2 (Page 57) -- 1994 Topps #511 Devon White (17 votes)

def.

#15 (Page 24) -- 1970 Topps #213 Andy Etchebarren (16 votes)

Two of the four matchups last week were decided by a single vote: one resulting in a big upset (Gagne over Robinson) and the other narrowly avoiding an even bigger one (White over Etchebarren).

I try to remain as impartial as possible as I watch the votes tally up, but I have to admit I would've been crushed if Devon White would've been tossed so early. That's one of my personal favorite cards in the whole frankenset, and it took a late rally for him to even survive the first round.

So, thanks for that, voters!

----------------------------


And so we move on to the fourth and final region of the frankenset bracket: the Palmer Region, named after Lowell Palmer, the coolest dude in the history of baseball cards.

Let's check out the matchups.





#1 (Page 60) -- 1975 Topps #533 Rudy Meoli

VS.

#16 (Page 27) -- 1974 Topps #238 Fran Healy





#8 (Page 50) -- 1994 Stadium Club #448 Erik Pappas

VS.

#9 (Page 44) -- 2001 UD Victory #396 Wilton Guerrero





#5 (Page 1) -- 2018 Stadium Club #9 Zack Godley

VS.

#12 (Page 67) -- 1969 Topps #603 Joe Keough






#4 (Page 54) -- 1996 Collector's Choice #484 Rex Hudler

VS.

#13 (Page 21) -- 1977 Topps #187 Dick Pole

That's it for this week. The polls are now on the sidebar.

Happy voting!